Remember where you were when you read it in the papers yesterday, 15 August, just one day after Lammas. It’s a story that changes our whole picture of the Neolithic. Analysis of the Altar Stone at Stonehenge shows that it came from the Old Red Sandstone found in an area running up the eastern seaboard of Inverness and Easter Ross, out towards Elgin or northwards to north-east Caithness and Orkney. It’s a 6-tonne block, at the very heart of the monument, and it must have somehow been carried to Stonehenge.
And although it could in theory have come from anywhere along that long section of coast for the Moray Firth, the scale of activity in Neolithic Orkney revealed by the Ness of Brodgar excavations, now in their final week, makes it a front-runner.
The zircons of Lake Orcadie
The summary of the details of the research published in the journal Nature shows how neatly the connection was made. It involves analysis of tiny crystals found in fragments of the Altar Stone. The crystals go back a billion years, far beyond the time when the rocks of present-day Orkney were formed as sediments in a great lake, called today Lake Orcadie.
The rocks of today hold patterns from the past, such as fossil ripple-marks and mud-cracks, that tell the story of the lake, and of the rivers that carried sediment into it from the gradual erosion of mountains around. In the rocks of these mountains were tiny crystals – zircons, rutile and apatite – so tough and hard that they survived all the geological changes, and in the sediments of Lake Orcadie they became incorporated into the Orkney rocks, starting with the Old Red Sandstone. Geologists like the late Dr John Flett Brown spent a lifetime in building up a picture of Lake Orcadie, detail by detail. The new Orkney Landscapes website on which he worked with his friend and collegue, Dr Adrian Hall, goes deep into the story.
The world’s continents have gradually moved since those days. They’ve been slowly drifting at about the rate that our fingernails grow, but over hundreds of millions of years it adds up, and Lake Orcadie and the land that today is Scotland were in one continental section and the rest of Britain was in another section. That other section was younger, and so its Old Red Sandstone lacks the characteristic tiny crystals found in the rocks of the Orcadian Basin.
Thus the presence of those tiny crystals – zircons and apatite and rutile – in the Altar Stone at Stonehenge are markers of a northern origin. Formed in hot rock like granite a billion years ago, they existed in the heart of mountains, slowly eroded into the great Lake Orcadie, gradually compressed into rocks. The crystals survived upheavals of land and times of fire and ice; then in the later stages as humans came on the scene they were quarried and carried for building, and one of the blocks was taken on a journey south.
The Neolithic Revolution
Just to put the weight of the Altar Stone in context, it’s more than twice as heavy as a Transit van. It’s about the same weight as Renault Master truck. If the people of the Neolithic could move a 6-tonne block of stone from one end of Britain to the other, they have clearly to be extremely able. And indeed this puts the cap on a mass of evidence that has been accumulating for a long time. The people of the Neolithic were, for instance, the first plant breeders, and they did this so successfully that all our domesticated cereal crops of today are from their work. In Central America they took wild teosinte grass and transformed it into maize with such radical changes that it took DNA analysis to confirm the origins. If anyone today would like to try crossing wild grasses and selecting from the results and continuing to cross-breed they will have a task for a lifetime and beyond.
It’s no wonder then that Prof. Gordon Childe, the excavator of Skara Brae, spoke of the biochemistry of bread-making, and also “the chemistry of pot-making, the physics of spinning, the mechanics of the loom, and the botany of flax and cotton.”
The people of the Neolithic laid the foundations for all these skills and technologies that we apply today, and Gordon Childe described the totality of their achievements as the Neolithic Revolution.

Sailing Neolithic seas
One man who is going to be particularly interested in the new discovery is Dr Mark Cooper in Washington, USA. His profession is in Covid research but his deep interest of many years is in solving the big question of Neolithic ships. Their imprints are found on the landscape from the Mediterranean to Iberia, from Brittany to Cornwall, up through Ireland and Wales and the west coast of Scotland and on to Orkney – so they had to have ships capable of coping with open sea and areas of currents and tides and broken water; and we know that they could also carry cattle.
This means sturdy ships – and Dr Cooper points to the trimarans of the Pacific Islanders with their rugged seaworthiness and cargo capacity. And a trimaran, he notes, needs a heavy weight on its centre section, for which the kind of slab used at various Neolithic sites might be ideal. So a Neolithic ship might have as part of its very seagoing essence a long stone. And here are all the signs of one more technology to add to the picture of the Neolithic Revolution.
Neolithic thinking
One of the biggest challenges of all is to build an overall picture of the Neolithic world from the remarkable discoveries that the archaeologists are making. It’s the one that archaeologists like Prof. Colin Renfrew have long enjoyed, to be able to get a glimpse into the thinking of the people whose lives have left. Their role is like that of the detective who gathers the facts of the case from the evidence painstakingly assembled by specialists in varied fields, and then to try to develop a picture that encompasses them all. It is a bit like piecing together an image of a pot from fragments of broken pottery, and there is no one way of doing it, just a series of attempts combining data and disciplined imagination.
For the Neolithic mind there are several avenues of approach. One is to study older cultures that have survived into the present day and compare their patterns of life with the data from the past. This involves areas like social anthropology.
This approach can be expanded with mythology and folklore, which can reach us today through a long chain from the past. The fragments that come can sometimes mutate like genes, but as with genes and indeed as with the development of languages, there are ways of working backwards from the present to develop a picture of older origins. And indeed we have a story of stones for Stonehenge being carried across the sea.
It comes from the cleric Geoffrey of Monmouth who is the source of many of the tales about King Arthur and the wizard Merlin, who indeed he says was responsible for erecting the stones of Stonehenge, which he took across the sea from Ireland. This may seem strange, but studies of the smaller stones at Stonehenge, the bluestones, show that four of the five varieties of them come from the far west of Wales, at one part of the Preseli Hills in Pembrokeshire. This part of Wales had had Irish settlement and was ruled by Irish kings in the centuries before Geoffrey’s time. The archaeologist Prof. Stuart Piggott was highly critical of Geoffrey’s work in general – but in this case, he said, there might be a fragment of folk-memory of the actual moving of the stones.
Thinking about it just now, this is a bit like the zircons that found their way through many geological changes of context into eventually the Altar Stone at Stonehenge. Somehow a fragment of the story of the moving of the bluestones of Stonehenge has passed through various people and places and eventually found itself in Geoffrey’s book.
The Preseli connection was made in 1923 by the geologist H. H. Thomas, and subsequent chemical analysis has added support for this. He also suggested that the Altar Stone came from the Old Red Sandstone of south Wales, and it is this hypothesis that has now been shown to be incorrect.
Geoffrey of Monmouth was writing around the year 1136, just a year or so in fact before the founding of St Magnus Cathedral, so he was several thousand years removed from the time of the building of Stonehenge. But his stories are such a jumbled-up mix of information that it looks that he has gathered a lot from older sources and simply written the information down as he heard it in order to preserve it.

A floating stone
There are also in the old stories of Merlin several mentions of a “floating stone” – a stone that somehow floats on the water. And strangely in Orkney folklore there are references to a stone being brought across the sea by St Magnus – it is a seabeast that he turns into a stone.
But why go to the effort of bringing a stone across the sea? Here the Rangers at the Brodgar and Stenness sites can help visitors, as in their interest in all things new about the sites, they mention research that shows that the various stones at Brodgar seem to come from the directions they point towards. In other words, if you stand in the centre of the circle and look at particular stones and past them to the area of land in the distance, that’s where they come from. It’s almost as if each such stone represents a kind of essence of the places and people from where they come.
If this is the case then the circle at Brodgar involves a kind of coming-together of the various communities of which the mainland of Orkney is composed.

Together round the table
Geoffrey’s book is a bit like an old family trunk with a mass of letters and photos and keepsakes that has accumulated over the years and has all become entangled. Skilled scholars of several disciplines have sifted through particular parts – linguists and historians, mythologists and historians of religion – probing the nature of tiny pieces and slowly and carefully trying to see how some might fit together. Pictures have been built of a historical Arthur in Roman and Saxon times – several different Arthurs, with each so convincing that it is difficult to prefer any single one.
Some of those who have looked deeper into references to Merlin have argued that he is coming from an older layer that goes back to the Neolithic, and we have noted the reference to his role in the construction of Stonehenge. There are various references to another of his projects which also involves a construction on a grand scale and a coming-together of people – the construction of Arthur’s Round Table. There are some similarities with the stories of the construction of Stonehenge, and these have led some people to speculate that the Round Table might indeed be Stonehenge itself. This is not such a big leap as it might seem, as there are several stone circles in England that are called King Arthur’s Round Table.
And in the Arthurian stories that Geoffrey tells us, and mong the various people who he says came to join the Round Table, there are quite a number of references to Orkney, through the person of King Lot. He is a prominent figure, married to Arthur’s sister or half-sister. In Welsh mythology there is a figure called Lot with Neolithic links, particularly with holed stones.
If we look at holed stones in Orkney, we find an ancient tradition so rooted in Orcadian society that it survived Christianity and all the restrictions of the organised church – this is the custom of short-term marriages at the Stone of Odin in Stenness that used to stand just across the road from the Watchstone at the Brig of Brodgar. The name given by the Norse to the stone doesn’t alter the fact that short-term marriages for a year and a day – ‘handfast marriages’ – were part of the fabric of Celtic society and go back a long way. The pattern of handfast marriages is linked to the figure known in Ireland as Lugh and in Wales as Lot. There are a number of elements in Orkney that fit together around Lugh and Lot and holed stones, which may be remnants of an older pattern.
So it is interesting to note that when Geoffrey tells us that King Lot of Orkney was closely involved with the Round Table, we can find from Orkney folklore and tradition a connection with Lot. And now at Stonehenge itself we have a stone that may possible have come from Orkney itself.
This could mean then, that just as the stones at Brodgar seem to bring together the communities of Orkney, so too do the stones of Stonehenge somehow represent a bringing together, an alignment of Stonehenge with other places, one being a spot in the Preseli Hills, one being Orkney, and there may be other places that geologists will identify in future studies.
In each case the stone construction involves a bringing together, a connecting up in the world. Why was it so important to hold the world together? If we can answer that, we will know why they were built. But as of today we know that Neolithic society was not fragmented as our world is today: instead there were threads reaching out across the landscape holding it together into a connected whole.
For the history and philosophy of science, it is becoming clear that, as the anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss observed more than sixty years ago, there are two great peaks in science. One developed in the 17th century with the Newtonian Revolution and continues today; and the other was the Neolithic Revolution, which was developed by some of the ablest people who have ever lived. The challenge, he said, was to try to work out why between these two great peaks of human achievement there was such a long low plain in between.
Howie Firth will be speaking on The Bear and the Ship, tracing the origins of an old story from the Shetland island of Fetlar, on Friday 6 September at 9 pm.

